Bassenthwaite Lake Station, Cumbria. 06-November-2025.
This tasting was a comparison between the northern and southern hemispheres. Each pair of wines were the same grape but from opposite sides of the equator. All wines from Majestic.
It was a slightly smaller crowd than normal, so the wine tasting was held in the lovely saloon car which worked very well there, perhaps due to the openness of the carriage.
Name, Vintage, ABV, Retail Price, Hemisphere, Country
- Tasting notes
- Mary’s notes and star rating out of three
- My preferred hemisphere
For each pair of wines, a show of hands was taken to decide which hemisphere was the winner. Generally we were in agreement with the consensus. On our table my vote was: Northern hemisphere 3, Southern hemisphere 1.
1 Winzer Krems Gruner Veltliner 2024, 12.5% £11.50 Northern Austria
- Crisp and refreshing, look for peach and citrus with notes of mineral and pepper on the finish
- Pale lemon; zingy on nose, tart; citrus, good acidity, mineral, medium length ✱½.
A low score because Mary is not a fan of this particular grape variety!
2 Saint Clair Pioneer Gruner Veltliner 2021, 13% £15 Southern New Zealand
- Handpicked in a relatively warm vineyard that intensifies and ripens the characteristics. Look for stone fruits and white pepper on the nose and a fruity balanced structure with enough acidity to hold its own with curry or spices.
- Warmer/soft nose, green apple, citrus; richer, more body, much softer/not so acidic/bit flabby? ✱
- Preferred
3 Naudin Pere et Fils Chardonnay 13.5% £11.50 Northern France
- Made by one of the oldest mansions in Burgundy, this wine is remarkably aromatic with flavours of mango, peach and citrus. Fresher than its southern hemisphere counterpart it will pair well with white fish.
- Light nose, not oaked / not much oak; green very slight butter; fresh, sharpish, green, pepper. More like Chablis ✱✱
- Preferred
4 Luis Felipe Edwards Gran Reserva Chardonnay 2024, 13.5% £11 Southern Chile
- From one of the largest family-owned vineyards in Chile, the fine wines produced offer great value for money. This is a rich, creamy Chardonnay with notes of tropical pineapple, mango, butterscotch and vanilla and a gentle nuttiness. Great with creamy chicken.
- More open, stronger nose, peachy, tropical, buttery; gentle, tasty, tropical, vanilla/butterscotch; decent length ✱✱
Note: comparison of these last two was probably as much about the oak treatment as which hemisphere.
5 Le Grand Retour 2021, 12.5% £12 Northern France
- Wine production of the Malbec grape began in South-West France, specifically in Cahors where this wine comes from. This wine is exceptionally fruity with flavours of raspberry, blackcurrant and blackberries and gentle tannins. Great with roast pork!
- Not typical Malbec/Cahors. Mahogany with brown at rim; soft, fruity, slightly sweet, lighter nose, lighter body; soft, fruity, nice flavours, berry fruit fruits, soft tannins ✱✱½
- Preferred
6 Intacto Gran Reserva Malbec 2022, 13.5% £12 Southern Chile
- This Malbec has intense notes of black fruits, ripe cranberries and chocolate with some violet notes. A spell in French oak gives structure in the mouth. Great for pairing with slow-cooked meats or char-grilled barbecue foods.
- More purple; strong nose, vegetal, softer, fruity ✱✱
7 Chateau Sainte Michelle Cabernet Sauvignon 2022, 14% £18 Northern USA
- From the cooler Washington State, this wine is unlike anything we have tasted from the warmer producers of the USA. Sainte Michelle is Washington's most respected winery, named Winery of the Year no less than 22 times! Look for exceptional complexity and notes of blackcurrant and plums.
- Light nose, lovely nose, dark fruit, slight acetone?; yummy, dark fruit/plums, complex, some tannins but soft, good balance, great length ✱✱✱
- Preferred
8 Rustenberg Cabernet Sauvignon 2023, 14% £16 Southern South Africa
- Twice winner of Young Winemaker of the Year, Murray Barlow is one of South Africa's most exciting young producers reflected in thiswell-crafted Cabernet. Expect dark berries, tobacco, oak ageing and ideal for ageing. May need decanting. Northern v South 6th November 2025
- Softer, stronger nose; dark fruit, plums, tobacco, some tannins but more astringent, not as fruity, too young? ✱✱
They opened one last bottle for a supernumerary glass after which we staggered back to the Pheasant Inn for a completely unnecessary last pint of beer before bed.


























































